There are arguments for and against the spaying of bitches and the
castration of dogs. The discussion below highlights the major advantages
and disadvantages for neutering your pet.
FEMALE DOGS - BITCHES - SPAYING YOUR DOG
Spaying involves the surgical removal of both ovaries and the uterus
whilst under a general anaesthetic.
Advantages
Behavioural Reasons
• The behavioural problems seen in intact bitches are associated
with the bitch coming into season (being ‘on heat’).
Wandering, blood spotting and increased attractiveness to male dogs
are seen. Since a spayed bitch does not come into season these problems
are not seen.
Medical Reasons
• The older intact bitch commonly develops medical problems
that are either eliminated or greatly reduced by spaying
• Pyometra is a life threatening infection of the womb that
requires surgical removal. The risks of the anaesthetic are much
greater than that of a bitch which is under going a routine spay.
• False pregnancy is a condition seen in intact bitches about
2 months after they have been in season. It may take several weeks
to resolve and is likely to recur after subsequent seasons. The
bitch will often behave in a different way and may start to produce
milk.
• Spaying eliminates the possibility of ovarian and uterine
tumours
• The risk of mammary tumours (breast cancer) is reduced by
up to 90% in spayed bitches. The younger the bitch is when she is
spayed the greater the reduction. The effect is lost by about 5
years old.
| Age at Neutering |
Lifetime risk of malignant mammary tumours developing |
| Before 1st season |
0.05% |
| Between 1st and 2nd seasons |
8% |
| After 2nd season |
26% |
Reproductive Reasons
• After spaying, a bitch cannot become pregnant. It is not
uncommon for owners to ring us in a panic because another dog has
just mated their bitch.
Disadvantages
• Reduced activity is occasionally seen
• There is the risk of the anaesthetic and surgery, but in
young healthy animals this is negligible
• Obesity may be seen in spayed dogs- BUT it must be remembered
that it is not the spaying that causes obesity, it is excessive
food
• Urinary incontinence is occasionally seen as a complication
of spaying
MALE DOGS - CASTRATION - CASTRATING YOUR
DOG
Castration involves the surgical removal of both testicles under a
general anaesthetic.
Advantages
Behavioural Reasons
• Castration will often help to alleviate certain behavioural
problems such as destruction, aggression, dominance, urine marking
and wandering
• It must be remembered that not all such problems are hormonally
driven. Castration is often most effective in reducing these types
of behaviour if performed early in a dog’s life.
Medical Reasons
• The older ‘entire’ dog commonly has a number
of medical conditions that are not seen in castrated dogs. These
include prostatic problems (such as enlargement and cysts), testicular
tumours and tumours around the anus. In older entire dogs with any
of these problems, castration is often part of the treatment.
Reproductive Reasons
• After castration a dog is unable to contribute to the ever-expanding
population of unwanted dogs
Disadvantages
• Reduced activity is occasionally seen
• There is the risk of the anaesthetic and surgery, but in
young healthy animals this is negligible
• Obesity may be seen in castrated dogs – BUT it must
be remembered that it is not the castration that causes the obesity,
it is excessive food
WHEN TO HAVE YOUR ANIMAL NEUTERED
• The view of this clinic is that the advantages of neutering
outweigh the disadvantages. As mentioned in some of the above points,
the benefits are increased the earlier the surgery is performed.
• Our policy is to advise neutering for dogs and bitches at
about 6 months of age. For bitches this will mean before their first
season. Although there appears to be some confusion in the medical
literature, it would appear that certain breeds are more prone to
developing incontinence if they are spayed before their first season.
These breeds are Dobermans, Boxers, Old English Sheep Dogs, Rottweilers,
Weimerarners, Springer Spaniels, Irish Setters and Rough Collies.
For these breeds, the clinic’s policy is to advise the owner
of the increased risk and leave the final decision up to the owner.
• If a bitch has had a season, then spaying should not be
performed until 2.5-3 months after the season has finished
• The clinic’s policy for spaying pregnant bitches is
that it is not acceptable
|